ForumForum Games ► Mafia
that’s true, but i’d rather not die so soon. i’d like to think how much i’ve helped us would at least give me that honor, and i’d like to kill the mafia before they get the chance to kill someone else. that being said, lynch potato
  
I agree that beck has helped far too much for that to be a smart move for them as a Mafia.

So let's talk about how everyone has been cleared and maybe we missed something?

Do we keep forgetting that potato was jailed? How could they have killed?
  
Me, e-bag, Tinny - cleared by beck. Same logic I just gave for myself applies to e-bag and Tinny.
Bronco - tracked by Tinny last night. Still awaiting for confirmation from Ant that you would have seen something if they'd been Mafia and killed someone.

Potato, beck - not cleared.
  
Do we keep forgetting that potato was jailed? How could they have killed?

It's frankly unlikely in my estimation, but it is still possible that Potato's secretly been the (Mafia) Jailer this whole time.
  
Okay but how does clearing bronco as not lying and only targeting potato not confirm them as jailer?
  
I suppose it doesn't, but it does confirm him as town.

Edit: Sorry, misread your post. Disregard.
  
Okay but taking all of this into consideration, why on earth would beck be this helpful and back themselves into a corner? That makes no sense for a Mafia. If I was Mafia detective I would've prob built the trust and then said you (jaded) were scum since you've been so sus anyways.
  
Because if they say I'm scum, and then I turn out to be town, they've given themselves up. Perhaps they thought they could convince us that they can't be Mafia just because they're detective.
  
Okay. Basically the hard part here is that everyone else has basically been cleared. Maybe it was a misplay on beck's part, but still. I am finding it hard to believe we went from like 5 solid suspects before math's lynch and now we're down to 1 who has been a major help to the town? Are we sure we aren't missing anything here?
  
Are we sure we aren't missing anything here?

Yeah, I'm pretty sure. You, me, and e-bag have pretty airtight defenses, and for Bronco we're just waiting on confirmation from Ant that we're correct about how tracking a Mafia power role works.

I know I said earlier that I didn't think Ant was creative enough to have a Mafia Harlot, but that was mostly just an attempt to get y'all to trust me a bit. Ant has done "Oops! All Watchers" and stuff like that before. Ant is definitely creative enough to have a Mafia Detective. Maybe one game I'll actually get to be Mafia Harlot. That would be fun. Especially if the town had Vigilantes I had to dodge at night. Okay, I'm getting kinda carried away, but the point is that Mafia Detective is very possible.
  
Lol the joke about anty being not creative made me trust you less because I love anty!

I think we should hang tight for their response about the tracking and then go from there. It's totally possible I can only see one target or something, but I don't see that being very likely.
  
I suppose it doesn't, but it does confirm him as town.


And YOU wanted to lynch me!
  
Ant has done "Oops! All Watchers" and stuff like that before.

Love that quote. Now I've just thought of "Oops! All Idiots" and how chaotic that would be. This actually makes me suspect you less lmao.
  
This actually makes me suspect you less lmao.

But you shouldn't be suspecting me at all! We've been over this. Has my incessant posting in this thread done nothing?
  
Ah yea, my bad.
  
Actually, you know what? I don't think we even need to wait for Anty to respond. Even if we can't clear Bronco, we can still win. It begins with us voting Bronco.

If Bronco is Mafia:
  • We win. Hooray!

If Bronco is Town but not Jailer:
  • Potato must have been Mafia Jailer the whole time. We vote them off tomorrow and win. Hooray!

If Bronco is Town Jailer:
  • Beck must have been Mafia Detective the whole time. We vote them off tomorrow and win. Hooray!
  
We're not in a rush we should really just wait until we hear back.
  
i honestly don’t care what happens so long as we get the last mafiaso, i do agree that both bronco and potato are suspicious and i haven’t had the opportunity to check either one
  
Actually, you know what? I don't think we even need to wait for Anty to respond. Even if we can't clear Bronco, we can still win. It begins with us voting Bronco.

STOP TRYING TO LYNCH ME
  
Bronco.
  
bronco
  
I know at this point potato could make the vote happen, but we are only halfway into the day and Anty is clearly busy so I'm okay to wait on clearing up that my tracking was correct and he only targeted one person.
  
I think I'm going to wait a bit, too. I don't like dropping the hammer.
  
STOP TRYING TO LYNCH ME

I'll grant that my first "Vote Bronco" plan was imperfect, in that it assumed beck's innocence. But Operation: Vote Bronco: Version 2.0 is frankly a flawless strategy.
  
Its not!!!
  
Forum > Forum Games > Mafia